Take the 2-minute tour ×
Philosophy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for those interested in logical reasoning. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I understand that Kant remarked that Space & Time are forms that the intuition take. Would he also say that of the integers? Are they judgements? That is they lie within his Category of Quantity.

share|improve this question
    
Without answering your question fully: Kant definitely states that there is nothing else with the same status as time and space. –  iphigenie Jan 6 '13 at 23:34

2 Answers 2

Its impossible to predict what Kant would say exactly.

However the concept of Integers is not to be confused with sense of space,time and scale/quantity:

To intuitively observe and acknowledge the existence of an entity does not require a basis or prior memory of it, like there is this strange thing on the table. This is natural intuition of acknowledging existence of something.

However, to comprehend the quantity of such entities , a prior understanding (memory) of such entities is required. like now there are more of those strange things on the table. Else you might mistake a collection as a single object when you notice it for the first time (intuition explained in point 2 below will eventually resolve this). This is a composite natural intuition of quantity. Being composite means it depends roughly upon following intuitions:

  1. Acknowledge: Accepting and memorizing the existence of an object.
  2. Remember: Noticing the similarity of all those objects with, accepted definition. This also helps when we are capable of observing similar parts of an object and proceed to divide it further.
  3. Compare: Have a sense of contrast, a scale, that is differentiating between more and less, one and many. (let's say general readings from our biological sensors)

All these natural intuitions work together to make us capable of counting. Similar interplay of memory and intuitive acknowledgements and comparisons also brings us sense of time passing by , and a sense of distance/space. Like now those strange things on the table are becoming more and more, and now they cover the entire table.

Notice how our intuition works fine with the still unknown strange thing. Let's call these strange things Integers. Let them represent our sense.

share|improve this answer
    
So quantity is the form of a definite measurement? I assume that integers will be for Kant a later abstraction/fabrication. –  Mozibur Ullah Jan 23 '13 at 14:33
    
Intuitively, its not, but yes, with useful abstractions like Integers at hand, a precision can be imparted to concept of quantity. Intuitively, we can tell a quantity(sensory perception) is larger than or smaller than that. But, to really convey "by how much" , we utilize generally accepted abstractions like Integers. –  user2411 Jan 23 '13 at 17:18

Nobody can tell what Kant would say.

With regard of integer numbers being forms that the intuition take, I have to say that they aren't.

Neither space or time.

They are only physical properties, or mathematical entities.

Both physics and mathematics, are universal fields of study.

If some day we make contact with an extraterestrial civilization, I'm sure they will have physics and mathematics as fields of study.

We need integers to say how many instances there are of an idea within a given context, what ever that idea is.

Many interactions between physical entities, can only be described using integers.

A cell replicates itself an integer number of times.

share|improve this answer
    
Its a rhetorical question, obviously Kant is not around personally to answer this. But there are scholars interested in Kant, and I'm looking for a Kantian perspective on this question. –  Mozibur Ullah Dec 7 '12 at 15:30

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.