Can we express the present tense without indexicality?
If so, what would that expression refer to, a present that did not chnage tense?
Can we express the present tense without indexicality?
If so, what would that expression refer to, a present that did not chnage tense?
From the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on indexicals:
From More Structural Analogies Between Pronouns and Tenses by Angelika Kratzer:
Her paper then goes on to outline the other parallel she discovered. Additionally, the original paper she is referencing is here.
If we take a philosophical stance, as opposed to a purely linguistic stance, and we concern ourselves with propositions, then it is widely accepted that present tense propositions are inherently indexical. As outlined above, the argument is that the truth value of something such as "my dog is happy" can change from time t-naught to time t-one. Therefore, the propositions carry some indexical, and in certain circumstances anaphoric, structure to them. If a present tensed proposition is expressed without a use of indexicality it would still need to account for the fact the that its truth value could change at some later time, or have been different at an earlier time. The arguments above support the idea that this is synonymous with indexicality and therefore that would be impossible.