4

Several years ago, while studying philosophy, I recall reading in numerous sources that Dennett believed (or was interpreted as believing - by either Clark or Churchland [or Fodor?]) that it was language that basically transformed the brain into a symbolic machine (to loosely paraphrase - the point was that language had a massively transformative effect on the brain [or mind, I don't care which he referred to]).

Unfortunately, I no longer have any of the books/articles that I was reading back then, so I can't go back and check them all. I've been searching online for a day now and have been unable to track down any of these sources.

Does this ring a bell for anyone?

3

I found it. It was Clark paraphrasing him, in (at least) two articles:

As Rex Kerr suggested, it was indeed from Consciousness Explained. For instance, here is a quote from Clark's 1996 paper:

"Dennett depicts our exposure to linguistic bombardment (in the context of some small and subtle differences in initial hardware) as causing the development of a special kind of on-board computational device viz. a kind of classical serial processor implemented in the substrate of massively parallel, broadly connectionist, neural machinery."

1

Not exactly. I recall reading Dennett advocating or at least open to the idea that language structures the brain's other workings to a significant extent, though. One example is posted here.

I do not recall reading anything by Churchland that was paraphrasing this, and I haven't read enough Fodor or Clark to know if they would have.

  • Hmmm, this is very frustrating. I'm positive he was more explicit at some point, but I dunno why I can't find it. It must have been someone paraphrasing him... perhaps it was somewhere in the connectionist vs. computational debate. Anyhow, thanks for the suggestion! – EleventyOne Mar 18 '14 at 1:49

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.