I came across a validation method for testing the validity of a syllogistic argument which seems quite easier to grasp:

For example:

To test the argument:

no P is B  
some C is B  
Therefore, some C is not P 

1.) Star premise letters that are distributed and conclusion letters that aren't distributed.

2.) Then the syllogism is VALID if and only if every capital letter is starred exactly once and there is exactly one star on the right-hand side.

It becomes:

no P* is B*  
some C is B  
Therefore, some C* is not P 

Now, we can say that the argument is valid because it meets the requirements for it to be valid but I don't exactly understand what is the proof behind this star test method.

Such as where does the validation ideas come from and what is the answer to:

Why or what makes it valid when there is exactly one star on the right hand side?
Why or what makes it valid when a capital letter is starred exactly once?

  • You have to study the original article defining the method ... Oct 1 '14 at 6:18
  • I just took a look at it. It presents various methods for testing validation but it doesn't exactly explain why do you need to follow the steps in method in order to prove the validity. E.g. it tells me "Star the letters in premises and count the stars etc." but doesn't say why am I doing this.
    – cpx
    Oct 1 '14 at 6:45
  • I haven't read it; but I think that he has "simply" find a simple way to apply the traditional "meta-theoric" rules. See Aristotle's Logic : 5.5 Metatheoretical Results, e.g. : "1. No deduction has two negative premises. 2. No deduction has two particular premises", etc. Oct 1 '14 at 7:47
  • But these are also the rules or result. Is it possible I can know where do these come from or what is the proof that "no deduction has two negative premises".
    – cpx
    Oct 1 '14 at 10:18
  • 1
    The "technique" used by Aristotle is a "standard" one: counter-examples. In modern term, you show by a counter-example that from "some C is B" and "some B is D" you cannot conclude anything about C and D, like e.g. "some C is D". Oct 1 '14 at 11:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.