Here is the question from Language, Proof and Logic (LPL). Problem 13.30:

1. | Likes(carl, max)
2. | ∀x [∃y (Likes(y, x) ∨ Likes(x, y)) → Likes(x, x)]
?? | ∃x Likes(x, carl)

I haven't had an issue with any of the other questions in this chapter, but this one is really throwing me for a loop. I suppose my issues are caused by carl and max (not nice guys, apparently). I tried finding hints and solutions on the internet, but I couldn't find a solution nor something helpful enough anywhere. According to Trinity University, it requires not a single subproof. I tried this many ways, but always ended up at a dead-end. My most recent attempt was to add this:

3. | Likes(max, carl) ∨ Likes(carl, max)                    ∨ Intro, 1
4. | ∃y (Likes(y, carl) ∨ Likes(carl, y))                   ∃ Intro, 3

But that didn't get me anywhere… Fitch tells me that I may not use that to deduce that Likes(carl, carl) through → Elim. I tried to introduce ∀x first, but this did not help either. This is a very confusing problem for me.

  • @zagadka. In case the line "?? | Exists y(x, carl)" does not contains a typo: What is meant?
    – Jo Wehler
    Aug 11 '15 at 18:38
  • @jowehler I meant that the "??" represents whatever number that line happens to be, since I do not know that number. It is nothing important. I did miss "Likes" after the y, however. I fixed that.
    – zagadka314
    Aug 11 '15 at 18:53
  • Now remains my question why this line contains y and x? I suppose it should read either x or y.
    – Jo Wehler
    Aug 11 '15 at 19:05
  • @jowehler Ah! Sorry about that, it looks like there was a single lingering PEBCAK error ;-)
    – zagadka314
    Aug 11 '15 at 19:27

After your comments I assume the last line claims "Exists x Likes(x,carl)".

To prove the claim, take x = carl.

If in line 2 you take x = carl and y = max, then line 1 with Likes(x,y) implies Likes (x,x), i.e. Likes (carl, carl), q.e.d.

Do you agree?

  • That worked very well! And Trinity was right, no subproof needed!
    – zagadka314
    Aug 11 '15 at 20:59

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.