One basic tenet of the opponent process theory is that there is a gradual unbalancing of the relation between an emotion and its own counter agent. For example holding a bucket of bricks with a wire handle, the intensity of the pain which is generated also produces and correlates with the degree of relief once the bricks are put down. according to the theory over time the ratio shifts and more brick holding becomes required for diminishing levels of relief.

could this be interpreted as a thesis generating its antithesis?

  • 2
    Just in passing: Hegel never uses this "thesis-anthithesis-synthesis" language -- maybe you could specify your "Hegelian" reading here a bit further? – Joseph Weissman Aug 21 '12 at 21:33
  • a fair point. i can't claim to fully understand the dialectic as it's explained by Hegel, but in his notion of identity "Identity is the identity of identity and non-identity", it encompasses both what it is and its negation. At each moment in the 'holding bricks-not holding bricks' process there are the effects of both the pain and relief implicated in both the holding and the putting down, i think in a sense this may be seen as an "Identity [of] identity of identity and non-identity" – Dr Sister Aug 22 '12 at 5:49
  • do you guys get it though? i think maybe the question is a bit sparse for details.. its the assumption that relief is the negation of the pain in the brick holding example, so holding them contains both the pain of carrying, and the degree of relief that will be felt. I think insofar as relief is considered the negation pain, then this could be seen as similar to the idea of a phenomena being produced as an identity and an it's negation .. things encompassing what they are and also the forces which negate them, and yet they are experienced as a unified event as its effects are spread out – Dr Sister Aug 25 '12 at 9:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.