Let's say we have the following statement to serve as a starting point around which a debate can be centerd.

Man is immortal

Someone could say that man is mortal according to accepted scientific fact but that isn't actually an argument in itself.

A supportive argument playing on interpretation might be to say that man can be immortal through his works and influence.

One disconfirming argument might be to say that man is not immortal because of aging and in turn it should be proven that advanced aging can have mortal consequences.

So how can one check the validity of these arguments and any examples you might be able to come up with?

  • 1
    An argument needs one or more premises and a conclusion; thus, it is correct to say that the single statement "Man is immortal" is not an argument. – Mauro ALLEGRANZA Sep 9 '16 at 7:06
  • The assertion "Man is immortal" is not empirically supported, due to the fact that nobody knows man living or that live more than e.g. 200 years. – Mauro ALLEGRANZA Sep 9 '16 at 7:07
  • Man is immortal is an assertion rather than an argument; and by itself it makes no real sense since we see men live and die every day; where it can make sense is the context of some doctrine, say within Islamic or Christian notions of the soul; but you make no mention of this... – Mozibur Ullah Sep 9 '16 at 9:26
  • Hi all. Sorry but it seems that I introduced a red herring here. The statement Man is immortal is the starting point or given statement to debate about. The actual arguments I'm asking about and their validity is those that confirm or disconfirm that statement. – James P. Sep 9 '16 at 11:25
  • 1
    An logical argument does not "confirm or disconfirm" an assertion; a logical argument proves an assertion; of course, it proves is on the ground of some premises. We "verify" every day that heavy bodies fall on ground, but we prove that they do so deriving the law of free fall from the Newtonian axioms (sorry for the very rough example ...). – Mauro ALLEGRANZA Sep 9 '16 at 11:36

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.