You want your child to tidy up his room. What is the "right" thing to tell him?

A) aka "the easier way": you tell him he will get presents for christmas if his room is clean (Bonus: because Santa will be happy then).

B) You explain why a room is better tidied up than not.

A) is a lie. Is it ok to tell the lie because it is easier to convince the child that way?

In my opinion, truth is always more important. I used this example for the neverending discussion: is it ok if people are made to believe into something that is (possibly) not there, but helps them living their lives?

  • This sounds like you want a personal advice, you should add a little more context. Do you have a certain ethical framework in mind? – viuser Dec 25 '16 at 9:08

In this example, it would certainly be more moral to honestly convince the child than to lie in order to achieve this goal.

Here it is interesting to consider two elements of Kantian ethics.

  • The Universality Principle - if this action were universalised, would this be acceptable?

If applied to this situation, lying is no doubt not the most morally supported solution.

  • Personhood & Means to an End - Kant argues that it is immoral to use someone simply as a means to an end

i.e. Using the child as a means to an end would not be considered moral in this situation

In conclusion, truthfulness, simply as a consequence of these principles, would be considered a more moral solution than to lie to the child.

A different approach would be from the perspective of utilitarianism: which action will result in more morally acceptable consequences in the future?

In this case it is less obvious but nevertheless quite likely that truthfulness will help the child down the line (note that this is by no means guaranteed, but still a fairly reasonable approach).

The importance of truth in ethics arises simply due to the fact that alternatives to it either are not considered equally morally acceptable or can be expected to have more detrimental consequences int the future.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy