2

What is the relationship between "distributive justice" and equity? Are these two ideas synonyms?

  • These terms can be synonyms, antonyms, or anywhere in between. I don't think you need strict definitions, but you do need to provide the context where you're encountering these terms, so that the answers can speak to that context. – Dan Hicks Mar 16 '18 at 19:38
  • @Dan, I understand there is some fluidity in the meaning of these terms according to the context in which they are used. However, I haven't read and cannot see a situation in which these two ideas are antonyms. I would appreciate if you could point me to a context/situation like this – rafa.pereira Mar 16 '18 at 21:33
  • Hi, welcome to Philosophy SE. Please visit our Help Center to see what questions we answer and how to ask. One-line posts are discouraged because it is hard to tell from them what people are looking for. – Conifold Mar 17 '18 at 4:19
1

▻ DISTRIBUTIVE JUSTICE ('DJ')

DJ occurs in the allocation of rewards, resources, rights, obligations, costs and burdens - any benefit or disbenefit that has to be allocated to a number of people. If I slice a cake at a children's party, I divide the cake into equal portions : each child gets the same amount because I do not favour any particular child. In fixing salaries I might allocate payment on the basis of 'to each according to their work', 'to each according to their needs', 'to each the same' or some such formula or principle. In making redundancies - a disbenefit - I might 'let people go' on the basis that the newest staff are the first to lose their jobs.

▻ EQUITY

Equity applies not in the field of distribution of benefits or disbenefits (as above). It is mainly about fair exchange - the mutually beneficial transfer of valued resources. In any situation there is usually an input/ output ratio that is fair or would widely be judged to be fair. It is hard to fix or define this ratio in advance but, for instance, if your input was 12 hours' hard work in cleaning my house, and my output was a payment to you of $1 or £2 or €3, the ratio does not seem proper or right. My output (payment) is disproportionately low in relation to your input : there is an inequitable ratio.

▻ CONVERGENT USAGE

There are other uses or meanings of equity by which equity and DJ come out the same : some might say that if I pay different salaries to two groups of workers doing identical work in two different factories, this is inequitable. This reduces equity to a form of DJ : if this situation is inequitable it is because I am not paying to each according to their work.

The account given of equity at the start marks out different work for the terms 'equity' and 'DJ'. We need both concepts, not the reduction of equity to DJ.

  • Geoffrey, thank you for clarifying that Equity cannot be reduced to DJ. If I understand your answer correctly, both concepts refer in a way to the idea of proportionality in what individuals receive considering some criteria of need/contribution compared to what other individuals receive/need/contribute. In that sense, I think your question clarifies that in some cases the word equity can be used as a synonym do DJ – rafa.pereira Mar 16 '18 at 21:30
  • @rafa.pereira. Yes, you quite right : the two terms can be used as synonyms and I guess this best suits your purpose. Is my answer more helpful now ? I've reworded it. Best - Geoffrey – Geoffrey Thomas Mar 16 '18 at 22:07
  • @rafa.pereira. I have revised my answer. I think you are interested in how equity and distributive justice can be equated -how they can amount to the same thing. Might you be inclined to assess my answer with a vote, one way or the other ? Best - Geoffrey – Geoffrey Thomas Mar 17 '18 at 11:47
  • @rafa.pereira. Response appreciated - Geoffrey – Geoffrey Thomas Mar 17 '18 at 12:53

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.