0

Suppose statement S is talking about concept C. There are 4 different possibilities:

  1. S is subjective and C is vague.
  2. S is objective and C is definite.
  3. S is subjective and C is definitie.
  4. S is objective and C is vague.

There are many obvious examples for 1 and 2. It seems to me that 3 is impossible. My question: Is 4 possible? If so, please provide an example.

Update: I have edited the question. In the previous version, I asked about two examples:

A. Bob is prettier than Charlie

B. Alice believes that Bob is prettier than Charlie

1

Something subjective is something relative while something objective is something universally valid.

"prettier" is something subjective by default because there is no universal rule, law or convention to define the specifications for it.

"Believes" are also something subjective because they have no actual foundation, therefore it cannot be defined as something objective.

Of course, we may take an extreme example of one of the subjects having his face ripped off or something like that, in which case any normal person would say that the other one is prettier, but even in this case there can be perspectives, there can be others even if at a rate of 1 in a million or so that would find the face ripped off subject prettier compared to the other.

So not even an extreme example cannot turn the B statement into something objective.

  • I just edited my question before seeing your answer. I apologize, but your answer is still relevant. – Asmani May 24 '18 at 12:24
  • Well, if we take physicalism for granted, maybe it's objectively verifiable if someone believes in something? – Asmani May 24 '18 at 12:26
  • No, because a believe is not checkable or quantifiable. After-edit - partially yes, because you can objectively determine that C is something vague. You should put back the initial content also, the current answer does not make any sense after your edit. – Overmind May 24 '18 at 12:39
  • You're right, I added an update. – Asmani May 24 '18 at 12:57
1

Something is subjective when it is caused by a person. "The chicken tikka masala is too spicy" would be a subjective statement because it is either true or false depending on the person saying it.

Something is vague when there is no sensible boundary such that its extent is known exactly. "Too spicy" is vague because there is no way that the transition between "too spicy" and "not too spicy" occurs at an exact place.

Vague concepts are the subject of the "sorites paradox" (or "paradox of the heap"), in which you remove grains from a heap of sand until what's left is "not a heap". We learn that although "heap" is a meaningful concept, it is vague; it's a good thing that there's nothing important that comes of being "a heap"! (I sure wouldn't want to order "a heap" of Cheerios on Amazon... I might get two Cheerios in a bag)

I think that "This food is too spicy" is subjective and definite... I won't eat it, but perhaps somebody else will. Also, "This is a heap of sand" is objective and vague.

Cheers!

  • Thanks. If spicy is definite, then it has a clear definition. What is that definition? – Asmani May 24 '18 at 13:28
  • Spicy is vague, but "too spicy" is definite: I won't eat something that's too spicy. "This food is spicy" would be vague as well as subjective. – elliot svensson May 24 '18 at 14:11
  • This is a heap of sand is not objective in your usage. This is a heap of sand would always have to be the same truth value for it to be objective. The moment it can be FALSE your claim is non-objective. Objectivity requires the truth value to never change. – Logikal May 24 '18 at 14:24
  • I guess I was imagining something that weighs between 25-50 lb, which for sand is objectively "a heap". True that "this is a heap" could also be said about a boundary condition, in which the vagueness causes human judgment / subjectivity to enter the equation. – elliot svensson May 24 '18 at 17:34
  • 1
    @Asmani, I suppose it would be objective to say it that way. But to hide the threshold by saying "it's too spicy" is subjective--- the same words by someone else have different truth values. – elliot svensson May 26 '18 at 13:18

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.