2

Let's say I have an argument with premises P, Q and R, with a conclusion S. But let's also say that Q and R are sufficient to conclude S. But having P as a premise doesn't affect the argument in any meaningful way, it's just an unnecessary premise.

If you do include P as a premise, is the argument still considered valid even if you could omit it?

4

Yes, if you add a redundant premise to a valid argument, the resulting argument is also valid.

If the resulting argument were invalid, that would mean that there is a case in which all the premises (say, P, Q, R) are true and the conclusion false. But then the original argument would be invalid as well, because there is a case in which its premises (Q and R) are true and the conclusion false. So adding premises cannot make a valid argument invalid.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.