what is being argued to Plato's theory of the forms in this passage(this is a dialogue):

Well, said Parmenides, and what do you say of another question? What question?

I imagine that the way in which you are led to assume one idea of each kind is as follows:—You see a number of great objects, and when you look at them there seems to you to be one and the same idea (or nature) in them all; hence you conceive of greatness as one.

Very true, said Socrates.

And if you go on and allow your mind in like manner to embrace in one view the idea of greatness and of great things which are not the idea, and to compare them, will not another greatness arise, which will appear to be the source of all these?

It would seem so.

Then another idea of greatness now comes into view over and above absolute greatness, and the individuals which partake of it; and then another, over and above all these, by virtue of which they will all be great, and so each idea instead of being one will be infinitely multiplied.

  • Would you have a source for the quote including translator. Welcome! – Frank Hubeny Jul 6 at 23:12
  • thank you. this is an excerpt from Plato's Parmenides. i think it is an objection to Plato's theory of the forms. I just need clarification on what is being argued here. – miranda Jul 6 at 23:20
  • This page contains an in-depth analysis of this argument, which he refers to as the Third Man Argument (TMA): faculty.washington.edu/smcohen/320/tmalect.htm – transitionsynthesis Jul 7 at 1:36
  • This is known as the third man argument (after analogous argument against forms in Aristotle, which uses men instead of greatness). To unify greatness and the form of greatness, one needs a third form, and so on, hence forms of greatness are pointlessly multiplied to infinity and never unified under a single form. – Conifold Jul 7 at 5:01
  • thank you so much! this really helped – miranda Jul 7 at 19:48

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.