-1

Let's set some context:

Person A and Person B have a group project. They are both assigned a slide (Slide A for Person A and Slide B for Person B)

Person A has finished his slide, yet Person B hasn't.

Person A: "Are you going to finish your slide?"

Person B: "Yes, I will finish my slide tonight." Let's say Person B is not lying.

Would this statement "I will finish my slide tonight." be considered a fact (about the future)?

How do we know that even though he is not lying about doing it, he will actually do it?

  • 5
    "I will finish my slide tonight" is a shorthand for "I intend to finish my slide tonight, and I am confident that I can", so it is not a statement about the future. It is a statement about intent in the present, and it is a fact if the person is not lying or mistaken/delusional, i.e. if they truly have this intent and confidence. – Conifold Jul 2 at 3:08
  • What does "slide" mean? – gonzo Jul 2 at 3:22
  • @gonzo It's a single page in a presentation, e.g. in PowerPoint. In old times they were literally put on film slides and projected onto a screen. – Conifold Jul 2 at 5:47
1

No, person B is stating a future contingent until the truth is actually determined.

Some other statements about the future might arguably be facts though, like "the sun will rise at such time tomorrow".

If person B says "I want to finish my slide tonight" that can be a fact, if it is actually true. What matters is if it's true or not. Whether you know it to be true is a separate question.

| improve this answer | |
1

By definition, it is either true now or it is false now that the slide will be finished tomorrow.

The fact that something is true doesn't imply that we know it is true.

A fact is a state of affairs we know to be the case. It is certainly not the case that anyone would know for a fact that some slide will be finished tomorrow. We don't even know that there will be a tomorrow to begin with.

We don't know the future, as far as I am aware, and so we don't know future facts, and we don't even know that there will be a future to begin with.

| improve this answer | |
1

Don't need to go far to describe the problem, which is purely conceptual.

A fact is an observation performed in the past (or the present, which is just our short-term memory, that is, a recent past). Not in the future.

A situation that will occur in the future can never be a fact, including the sun coming out tomorrow. It is highly probable, but it is not yet a fact. Person B having the intention to finish does not imply it will occur.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.