How to prove A or C from premises A or B and -B or C. Am using fitch and have been stuck on this for an hour
2 Answers
Our goal is a disjunction. Working forward (from the premises) seems a good option. As A v B and ¬B v C both have a disjunction as its main logical connective, we will attempt to use Disjunction Elimination rule. The proof skeleton, would be:
1. | A v B
2. |_ ¬B v C
3. | |_ A
4. | | A v C v Intro: 3
5. | |_ B
6. | | |_ ¬B
7. | | | ⊥ ⊥ Intro: 6,5
8. | | | ...
9. | | |_ C
10. | | | ...
11. | | ...
12. | A v C v Elim: 3-4, 5-11
Can you complete the proof, now ?
- (A v B)
- -(B v C)
- | A___ ASSUME
- | (A v C) [v-introduction, 3]
- | B___ ASSUME
- | -B___ ASSUME
- | ⊥ [⊥-introduction, 5,6]
- | (A v C) [⊥-elimination, 7]
- | C___ ASSUME
- | (A v C) [v-introduction, 9]
- | (A v C) [v-elimination, 2, 6-8, 9-10]
- (A v C) [v-elimination, 1, 3-4, 5-11]