From what I haved gathered from the first sections of the Critique, Kant wants to resolve the problem of induction by adding the a priori concept of (the necessity between) cause and effect to our synthetic a posteriori experiences of what Hume would call "constant conjunctions" in order that we may make synthetic a priori judgments about causation, instead of solely relying on inductive reasoning about constant conjunctions.

While this does seem necessary to solve the problem, it seems to me like this is not sufficient to solve the problem.

My reasoning for this is that it seems perfectly possible that we experience a constant conjunction and add the principle of causation to it, only for us to later find out that it actually is not a necessary causal connection after all, i.e the famous black swan example.

So how does Kant propose we establish that we've encountered the right kind of constant conjunction to add the principle of causation to?

  • IIRC Kant can be understood as favoring a modus tollens-focused model of causal judgments (or something along those lines). – Kristian Berry May 4 at 0:43
  • Kant wasn't trying to turn induction into deduction; that is, he was not trying to come up with a system where inductive reasoning could not go wrong; he was just trying to justify the use of causal judgment in general. – David Gudeman May 4 at 20:18
  • Kant proposes that we can establish this only plausibly: "Necessity and strict universality are therefore secure indications of an a priori cognition... But since in their use it... is often more plausible to show the unrestricted universality that we ascribe to a judgment than its necessity, it is advisable to employ separately these two criteria". In other words, it is only generalities about causality that are a priori (e.g. "every alteration must have a cause"), deciding whether this or that conjunction is causal or not is left up to empirical investigation. – Conifold May 4 at 20:20

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.