0

Max Tegmark is perhaps the best example, with his idea which basically proposes that every mathematically possible universe exists.

Are there any other examples of physicists with a similar line of thought (preferably living physicists)?

1
  • 1
    Tegmark is a Platonist, but positing that mathematical universes physically exist is not part of Platonism as such. Roger Penrose is another Platonist, as are many proponents of string theory as "theory of everything", like Greene. See Gopman's thesis on Platonism in modern physics.
    – Conifold
    Sep 26 at 5:20
1

Tegmark is only a mathematical Platonist and not a full blown Platonist and hence not a Platonist at all given how important a role the forms of the Good and the One play in Plato's philosophy.

One Einstein quote says his god was Spinoza's god. As Spinoza simply presented Platonic philosophy in geometric form, one can say that Einstein was a Platonist.

Newton, pushed away from the Trinitarianism of his time. As he also said:

Plato is my friend, Aristotle is my friend but truth is a greater friend.

One can state he was acquainted with Plato's phikosophy. This coupled with the fact he was a avowed Unitarian suggests that he was a Platonist.

Feynman in one of his later writings, The Meaning of Everythimg, appeared to endorse Christianity and given his interest in philosophy and the Platonist inflection of Christian philosophy may have endorsed Platonism.

4
  • Thank you @MoziburUllah do you know about any platonist living physicist?
    – vengaq
    Sep 25 at 22:56
  • In most contemporary usage Platonism with a capital P is used for Plato’s philosophy of Ideals, which has very few adherents today. Whereas platonism with a small p is used to identify the belief that abstract object like math, morality, and sociological constructs have real existence. Large P Platonists are also small p platonists but not vice versa.
    – Dcleve
    Sep 26 at 15:59
  • @Vengaq: Don Page certainly is - he's also one of the worlds leading experts on theoretical gravitational physics and cosmology. Check out his discussion with Sean Carroll. Sep 30 at 7:01
  • @Dcleve: Philosophical Christianity and Islam has a great deal of overlap with Platonism, so I'd say, that Platonism is still a strong current in todays debate. Personally, I'd distinguish between Plato's Platonism and Mathematical Platonism rather than relying on distinguishing by relying on initial letrer capiralisation. It's easily misused, misunderstood and abused. I think it's best to use proper names. Sep 30 at 7:06
0

Platonism, the acceptance of the “reality” of abstract objects, is not a widely understood question outside philosophic circles, so explicit statements by physicists will be rare to find.

An oblique way to ask the question is whether they accept that matter is primary, or math. And if one does that, most theoretical physicists are either platonists or idealists. A significant number of theoretical physicists think that physics reduces to math. And if that is true — math would be the substrate for everything, which is a very platonist view.

Additionally, the motto of many quantum physicists, and most of those that advocate for the majority Coopenhagen interpretation of QM, is “shut up and calculate”, IE do the math, that is all that matters, any further speculation or theorizing about what the math MEANS is unneeded! Because doing the math is all the meaning there is.

Additionally, any advocate of B theory of time, and treating the present and causation as illusions, is treating math as primary over experience and evidence.

I have one quote to offer, from physicist Sean Carroll, who was asked what reality is:

“The best answer we can give is that reality is a vector in Hilbert space. This is the technical way of saying that reality is described by a single quantum mechanical wave function.”

Carroll is both a platonist and an idealist, and an advocate of scientism, the reduction of everything to physics.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.