I sometimes wonder if "I" would have existed if another sperm had fertilized the egg that was to become "me". Is this even answerable in any meaningful way? I sit here and experience myself as a unique individual and I speculate that everybody else feels the same about their own unique consciousness and self-awareness. So if a different sperm had fertilized the egg that was there when I was conceived, would "I" have come into existence nine months later, but with a different set of genes?

  • 1
    This is a great philosophy question --I gave you an upvote for that --but it's not a good fit for this forum because there is no defined answer. You might manage to keep it from being closed if you make it more specific --i.e. "what would philosopher X say about this question?" or "how could we address this question in light of X-ism?" – Chris Sunami supports Monica Feb 18 '14 at 16:56
  • 1
    If a different sperm from same the same man fertilized the same egg, 25% of the embryo's DNA would be different from yours. The result would be similar to your semi-identical twin. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin#Semi-identical_twins – obelia Feb 18 '14 at 17:59
  • You could also think about the differences and similarities among identical twins (same genetic info) and siblings (with 50% similar genetic info). – obelia Feb 19 '14 at 8:44

Studies tend to show that about 50% of variability in behavioral traits is explained by genes and 50% by environment. Unlike with identical twins, your other could have a pretty similar experience to you. So, with 25% of your genes different, your other would be up to about 8x more similar to you than a random person is, and would have many of the same experiences and memories.

But of course that very-similar-person's consciousness wouldn't be yours; you are by hypothesis not around to experience anything. You can't really arrange it so you can without breaking the whole premise. So the other-you is identifiable as the most you-like entity in that hypothetical universe, and that is about as far as it goes.

| improve this answer | |
  • While I would tend to agree with some of this. There seems to be a giant root assumption that goes unstated about the nature of consciousness and its relation to the physical brain. The seemingly appropriate follow-up question is this: did "I" exist a minute ago, a day ago, a year ago? It seems like answers as to why these questions are affirmative or negative would explain what your answer really means. – virmaior Feb 19 '14 at 5:54
  • I think the answer to the question "did 'I' exist a minute ago, a year ago" is yes. At least in the context of my own self-awareness and memory of who I was a minute ago. – Steve d'Apollonia Feb 19 '14 at 13:07
  • Although my experiences and physical parts are constantly changing I still think I retain a definite self-awareness that is specific and unique to "me". On the other hand I suppose a grain of sand on the beach is also unique - just as unique as a particular mosquito, bacteria, or cloud formation. Could it be that this concept we call "self-awareness" is merely a kind of biological feed-back loop or memory polling function that evolved as just another component in our biology - from single cells all the way to warm blooded mammals with backbones and a self-polling memory function in our brain? – Steve d'Apollonia Feb 19 '14 at 13:15
  • @Steved'Apollonia that may all be true... but I think Rex needs to indicate his answer to this question and explain why the different genetic material matters in a way that different matter does not. – virmaior Feb 19 '14 at 17:09
  • @virmaior - I'm arguing that the premise makes it an unanswerable question when asking it in the "did 'I' exist a year ago" sense. When asking it in another sense, we can tell that this person is likely to be Steve-like, but somewhat distinct: perhaps less different than identical twins (save for looks) are to each other, but there still would be substantial differences based on the genetic contribution. – Rex Kerr Feb 20 '14 at 1:00

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.