New answers tagged justification
1
vote
Can private experiences justify private belief in supernaturalism?
Is it ever rational or justified to believe in the supernatural on the basis of private experiences (of the kind for which publicly accessible evidence can hardly be produced)?
Anyone who is utterly ...
- 179
0
votes
Can private experiences justify private belief in supernaturalism?
Well, some things are meant to be subjective ; no-one can tell you whether your love for someone is rational or not; love is supernatural after all, perhaps life too. It's what YOU believe that counts ...
- 1,680
0
votes
Can private experiences justify private belief in supernaturalism?
There can't be a black and white answer. It depends on the nature of the statement believed, your standards of justification, and whether you judge they have been met. For example, millions of people ...
- 13.3k
5
votes
Accepted
Can private experiences justify private belief in supernaturalism?
It is important to discriminate between certainty and knowledge. Certainty is a subjective feeling, which can be highly convincing for oneself. Knowledge requires the ability to give supporting ...
- 24.3k
1
vote
To what extent is intersubjective agreement required for one to be justified in trusting one's own subjective experiences?
This is an extremely straightforward application of Bayes' theorem.
Suppose we give prior values to:
The probability P(H) that person A has an hallucination (using what we know about A, or what we ...
- 573
1
vote
To what extent is intersubjective agreement required for one to be justified in trusting one's own subjective experiences?
Strictly speaking, intersubjective agreement is in-and-of-itself a personal subjective experience, and is therefore not entirely trustworthy.
In short; intersubjective agreement isn't a foolproof way ...
- 418
2
votes
To what extent is intersubjective agreement required for one to be justified in trusting one's own subjective experiences?
Trust or distrust is a subjective experience. It arises both in the presence and in the absence of intersubjective agreement. Justification efforts sometimes arise alongside the trust or distrust in ...
- 634
4
votes
To what extent is intersubjective agreement required for one to be justified in trusting one's own subjective experiences?
There should always be some room for skepticism, even in the face of high intersubjective agreement.
For example, there are many common optical illusions, which most people mis-interpret (even if you ...
- 1,108
4
votes
To what extent is intersubjective agreement required for one to be justified in trusting one's own subjective experiences?
To what extent is intersubjective agreement required for one to be justified in trusting one's subjective experiences?
There's no convention by which one can answer this question across all societies....
- 22.8k
4
votes
To what extent is intersubjective agreement required for one to be justified in trusting one's own subjective experiences?
I just watched a Star Trek episode in which someone says "I know this, trust me". The captain immediately swings into action, because he knows the person and trusts their judgement. In the ...
- 1,850
5
votes
Accepted
To what extent is intersubjective agreement required for one to be justified in trusting one's own subjective experiences?
Intersubjective agreement isn't required at all, strictly speaking. But it does help.
For one particular topic, if we grant that some reasonable portion of humans are rational, it suggests that those ...
- 5,522
0
votes
Can I know something but not be able to justify it to anyone else?
Yes , you can know something and not be able to justify. It’s called faith. Faith doesn’t need justification always. For example - so many people believe in God but they can not always be able to ...
- 1,841
0
votes
Can I know something but not be able to justify it to anyone else?
Most everyday examples should be justifiable to most people. The scenario where you can't prove the bus is likely to be provable to most people. The condition of "anyone" makes it more ...
- 31
4
votes
Can I know something but not be able to justify it to anyone else?
The skeptic view (in the sense of questioning beliefs, not radical philosophical skepticism) is, roughly speaking, that if you cannot justify something, you shouldn't believe it.
The above means being ...
- 5,522
3
votes
Can I know something but not be able to justify it to anyone else?
The examples @Dcleve gives in his answers for knowing "from pure first person thinking" seem to me examples for the experience of inner certainty. In most cases there is no problem to ...
- 24.3k
8
votes
Can I know something but not be able to justify it to anyone else?
Yes. And this is true of most of what we know.
Almost everything we know, we learn thru first person empiricism. It may be possible to translate and detail at least some first person empirical ...
- 10.5k
4
votes
Accepted
Can God make the belief in His own existence justified (if He exists)?
Reliabilist and skeptical claims notwithstanding...(as pointed out by Conifold)
this is the crux of the atheistic Argument from Divine Hiddenness:
(1) Necessarily, if God exists, then God perfectly ...
- 1,409
0
votes
Can God make the belief in His own existence justified (if He exists)?
According to Immanuel Kant, it's not logically possible for God to reveal Its existence to us in intuition, since the mismatch-of-type between empirical and divine natures is too extreme for us to ...
- 12.4k
-1
votes
Can God make the belief in His own existence justified (if He exists)?
If you consider God as an independent being of some sort, then you are probably thinking of an extraordinary act of some kind – like a show – that will leave no doubt about His greatness.
On the other ...
- 1,680
3
votes
Can God make the belief in His own existence justified (if He exists)?
Nothing is preventing God from revealing to you in person if you are eligible. Just like this site doesn’t tolerate every kind of question and every kind of person for a good reason , similarly God ...
- 1,841
2
votes
Can God make the belief in His own existence justified (if He exists)?
I do not know whether He/She can. Actually He does not want.
A mighty personal being, having created the world but not showing any interest to communicate in an understandable way with his creatures, ...
- 24.3k
Top 50 recent answers are included