Skip to main content
Rushi's user avatar
Rushi's user avatar
Rushi's user avatar
Rushi
  • Member for 5 years, 5 months
  • Last seen this week
About

Outstanding Problems in Philosophy

  1. Anyone who denies Sapir-Whorf is monolingual — at least in thought
  2. Anyone who denies Plato is denying that they ever had a clear idea — i.e. a thought not moored to a specific point in spacetime. IOW every human is a Platonist modulo self awareness and labels
  3. And presentism is a more present problem than ever in history — Google makes so many more facts available than any library ever could, we also assume a right to more attitude

Reconciling the inexorable truth of Sapir Whorf relativism with the absolute necessity of Platonism is a real and pressing problem for philosophy.

It cannot of course be done because {Plato, Sapir, Whorf...} are dead.

The best solution we have is (e.g.) Eckhart Tolle — Now is more sacred than any other point in imagined time.
In the words of Ramana Maharshi:

Question: Someone referring a quote in the newspaper: Where psychology ends philosophy begins
Ramana: And where philosophy ends spirituality begins

But then that too is presentist!! Plato probably would not have recognized the difference between philosophy and spirituality 😇

2
gold badges
9
silver badges
37
bronze badges
47
Score
20
Posts
11
Posts %
39
Score
17
Posts
9
Posts %
39
Score
17
Posts
9
Posts %
31
Score
18
Posts
10
Posts %
29
Score
12
Posts
7
Posts %
21
Score
19
Posts
10
Posts %
Top posts
View all questions and answers